The reintroduction of ground-effect cars in the 2022 Formula 1 technical regulations led to the recurrence of porpoising, an aeroelastic instability characterized by violent, high-speed vertical oscillations of the chassis at telemetrically recorded frequencies between 4.8 Hz and 5.85 Hz. These vibrations are transmitted directly to the driver through the rigid seat, subjecting the spinal column to severe stress. Because the natural resonant frequency of the human lumbar spine is approximately 4 Hz, the porpoising load spectrum is extremely critical, preventing effective energy dissipation and inducing elevated peak forces on the driver's body. This thesis presents an evaluation of these biomechanical stresses using a static finite element analysis (FEM) performed in Abaqus. The primary objective is to investigate the stress and deformation state within a lumbar Functional Spinal Unit (FSU) subjected to maximum loading conditions derived from race telemetry data, mapping stress concentration regions and evaluating potential structural risks for the vertebrae and intervertebral discs. The three-dimensional spinal segment model comprises three adjacent vertebrae and two intervertebral discs. In accordance with the established modeling assumptions, the vertebrae were homogenized as isotropic cortical bone, while the intervertebral discs were defined using an equivalent elastic material model to represent their macroscopic structural response. Structural continuity and bonding at the interfaces between the vertebral endplates and disc surfaces were enforced using kinematic Tie constraints. The static analysis was carried out in the Abaqus Static, General module, applying a fixed boundary condition at the base of the structure and an equivalent compressive load on the top surface. This load combines the physiological preload with peak forces translated from vertical acceleration and bottoming-out telemetry data. Data extraction and post-processing were supported by custom scripts developed in MATLAB. Results from the static simulation reveal significant stress concentrations in the interface regions between the intervertebral discs and the vertebral endplates, identifying the most critical areas under peak loading conditions. The implemented approach confirmed the mechanical severity of the stresses transmitted to the driver, providing a valuable evaluation framework for understanding the phenomenon and supporting the design of future dampening and protection systems.
La reintroduzione delle vetture ad effetto suolo nel regolamento tecnico della Formula 1 (stagione 2022) ha determinato la comparsa del porpoising, un'instabilità aeroelastica che genera violente e continue oscillazioni verticali del telaio ad alta velocità, con frequenze telemetriche misurate tra i 4.8 Hz e i 5.85 Hz. Tali sollecitazioni vengono trasmesse integralmente al pilota attraverso il sedile rigido, investendo la colonna vertebrale. Poiché la frequenza di risonanza naturale del rachide lombare umano si colloca attorno ai 4 Hz, lo spettro di carico del porpoising risulta particolarmente critico, impedendo un'efficace dissipazione dell'energia e inducendo elevati picchi di carico sul corpo del pilota. Il presente lavoro di tesi affronta la valutazione di tali sollecitazioni biomeccaniche mediante l'implementazione di un'analisi statica ad elementi finiti (FEM) svolta nel software Abaqus. L'obiettivo principale è studiare lo stato tensionale e deformativo all'interno di un'unità spinale funzionale (FSU) lombare sottoposta alle condizioni di carico massimo derivate dai dati telemetrici di gara, al fine di individuare le zone di maggior concentrazione degli sforzi e valutare i potenziali rischi per le strutture vertebrali e discali. La modellazione tridimensionale del segmento spinale comprende tre corpi vertebrali adiacenti e due dischi intervertebrali. In accordo con le semplificazioni metodologiche concordate, le vertebre sono state modellate come osso corticale omogeneo ed isotropo, mentre i dischi intervertebrali sono stati definiti mediante un modello elastico equivalente capace di rappresentarne la risposta macroscopica globale. La continuità strutturale e l'adesione tra i piatti terminali vertebrali e le superfici dei dischi sono state garantite mediante l'applicazione di vincoli cinematici di tipo Tie. L'analisi statica è stata condotta nel modulo Static, General di Abaqus, applicando un incastro alla base della struttura e un carico compressivo sulla superficie superiore. Tale sollecitazione sintetizza il precarico fisiologico e le forze di picco derivanti dalle accelerazioni verticali registrate durante il porpoising ed i tamponamenti del fondo vettura. L'elaborazione e la gestione dei dati di output sono state integrate con l'ausilio di script dedicati in ambiente MATLAB. I risultati della simulazione statica evidenziano una significativa concentrazione delle tensioni nelle regioni di interfaccia tra disco intervertebrale e piatto osseo, individuando le aree maggiormente sollecitate sotto l'azione dei carichi di picco. L'approccio adottato ha permesso di confermare la severità delle sollecitazioni trasmesse al pilota, fornendo una base di valutazione utile per la comprensione del fenomeno e per lo sviluppo di future soluzioni di protezione e smorzamento.
L'EFFETTO DEL PORPOISING SULLA COLONNA VERTEBRALE DI UN PILOTA DI FORMULA UNO
ACONITO, ALESSIA
2025/2026
Abstract
The reintroduction of ground-effect cars in the 2022 Formula 1 technical regulations led to the recurrence of porpoising, an aeroelastic instability characterized by violent, high-speed vertical oscillations of the chassis at telemetrically recorded frequencies between 4.8 Hz and 5.85 Hz. These vibrations are transmitted directly to the driver through the rigid seat, subjecting the spinal column to severe stress. Because the natural resonant frequency of the human lumbar spine is approximately 4 Hz, the porpoising load spectrum is extremely critical, preventing effective energy dissipation and inducing elevated peak forces on the driver's body. This thesis presents an evaluation of these biomechanical stresses using a static finite element analysis (FEM) performed in Abaqus. The primary objective is to investigate the stress and deformation state within a lumbar Functional Spinal Unit (FSU) subjected to maximum loading conditions derived from race telemetry data, mapping stress concentration regions and evaluating potential structural risks for the vertebrae and intervertebral discs. The three-dimensional spinal segment model comprises three adjacent vertebrae and two intervertebral discs. In accordance with the established modeling assumptions, the vertebrae were homogenized as isotropic cortical bone, while the intervertebral discs were defined using an equivalent elastic material model to represent their macroscopic structural response. Structural continuity and bonding at the interfaces between the vertebral endplates and disc surfaces were enforced using kinematic Tie constraints. The static analysis was carried out in the Abaqus Static, General module, applying a fixed boundary condition at the base of the structure and an equivalent compressive load on the top surface. This load combines the physiological preload with peak forces translated from vertical acceleration and bottoming-out telemetry data. Data extraction and post-processing were supported by custom scripts developed in MATLAB. Results from the static simulation reveal significant stress concentrations in the interface regions between the intervertebral discs and the vertebral endplates, identifying the most critical areas under peak loading conditions. The implemented approach confirmed the mechanical severity of the stresses transmitted to the driver, providing a valuable evaluation framework for understanding the phenomenon and supporting the design of future dampening and protection systems.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Aconito_Tesi.pdf
File consultabile da postazioni biblioteca
Descrizione: elaborato di tesi
Dimensione
2.59 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.59 MB | Adobe PDF |
I documenti in UNITESI sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14253/111190